If there’s one beauty product that can instantly wake up your face, define your eyes, and make you feel like that girl, it’s mascara. But with so many formulas promising volume, length, and curl, how do you know which ones actually deliver?
Don’t worry, bestie—I put 2025’s hottest mascaras to the test so you don’t have to. From drugstore gems to luxury splurges, here are the top 5 mascaras that truly deserve a spot in your makeup bag.
1. Lancôme Le 8 Hypnôse Mascara – Best Overall
⭐ Rating: 9.5/10
💰 Price: $$$
This mascara is like the Rolls Royce of lashes—luxurious, weightless, and packed with conditioning serum to keep your lashes healthy while delivering insane volume. The soft-bristle brush ensures no clumps, just fluttery, feathery lashes that last all day. Plus, it’s infused with amino acids to actually strengthen your lashes over time.
🔥 Why We Love It:
✔️ Buildable, weightless volume
✔️ Nourishes and conditions lashes
✔️ Smudge-proof but easy to remove
💡 Best For: Anyone who loves high-end luxury mascaras with lash care benefits.
2. Maybelline Sky High Cosmic Black – Best Drugstore Pick
⭐ Rating: 9/10
💰 Price: $
Maybelline’s Sky High Mascara went viral for a reason, and in 2025, they leveled up with the Cosmic Black version. This one has a deeper, richer pigment for bolder lashes while keeping the same flexible brush that lifts, lengthens, and separates beautifully. If you want a drugstore mascara that competes with high-end brands, this is your girl.
🔥 Why We Love It:
✔️ Jet-black pigment for extra drama
✔️ Affordable & performs like luxury
✔️ Super long-lasting but not stiff
💡 Best For: Beauty lovers on a budget who want length & drama without clumps.
3. Too Faced Better Than Sex 2.0 – Best for Volume
⭐ Rating: 8.8/10
💰 Price: $$
Too Faced took their iconic Better Than Sex Mascara and somehow made it even better. More intense pigment, a smudge-proof formula, and extra lift—this new and improved version keeps your lashes looking thick and dramatic without flaking. The hourglass brush gives that instant false-lash effect, making this a go-to for bold lash lovers.
🔥 Why We Love It:
✔️ Intense, voluminous lashes
✔️ Doesn’t flake or transfer
✔️ Works even on stubborn straight lashes
💡 Best For: Anyone who wants bold, statement lashes in just a few coats.
4. Tarte Tartelette Tubing Mascara – Best for Length & Definition
⭐ Rating: 8.5/10
💰 Price: $$
If you struggle with short lashes or mascara smudging, tubing mascaras are the way to go. Tarte’s Tartelette Tubing Mascara coats every lash with a water-resistant formula that won’t budge, yet washes off effortlessly with warm water. It’s perfect for natural, defined lashes that look like yours but better.
🔥 Why We Love It:
✔️ Tubing formula = zero smudging
✔️ Makes short lashes look long & defined
✔️ No harsh rubbing needed to remove
💡 Best For: Anyone who wants long, defined lashes without smudging.
5. Dior Diorshow Iconic Overcurl – Best Curl & Lift
⭐ Rating: 8.3/10
💰 Price: $$$
Dior’s Iconic Overcurl Mascara is a lash curler in a tube. If your lashes tend to fall flat, this formula lifts and holds a curl all day while adding soft volume. Plus, it’s enriched with cotton nectar to keep your lashes nourished and healthy. Think red-carpet lashes, but effortless.
🔥 Why We Love It:
✔️ Holds curl all day
✔️ Nourishing formula that strengthens lashes
✔️ Luxurious brush for maximum lift
💡 Best For: Those who need extra curl and lift for a wide-eyed look.
Final Thoughts – Which Mascara is Right for You?
✨ Want the best overall mascara? Lancôme Le 8 Hypnôse
✨ Need a budget-friendly option? Maybelline Sky High Cosmic Black
✨ Love thick, bold lashes? Too Faced Better Than Sex 2.0
✨ Prefer long, natural-looking lashes? Tarte Tartelette Tubing Mascara
✨ Struggle with straight lashes? Dior Diorshow Iconic Overcurl
No matter your lash goals, 2025 is serving up some game-changing mascaras! Have you tried any of these? Let me know your go-to lash obsession in the comments! 💖✨
The Aphrodite Collective 
Leave a comment